In a recent revealing video, popular mechanic and YouTuber Scotty Kilmer tackles some of the prevalent misconceptions about electric vehicles (EVs). Kilmer, who has over 56 years of experience in auto repair, shares his insights on the real challenges and hidden costs associated with electric cars. He argues that the media often overlooks these issues, painting an overly rosy picture of EVs. Let’s take a look at what he had to say.
Battery Complications
One of the critical points Kilmer makes is about the complexity of electric car batteries. He explains that while electric cars have a large main battery, they also rely on a smaller, conventional 12-volt battery to power the vehicle’s electronics and start the car. This smaller battery needs regular maintenance and replacement, much like in traditional gasoline-powered cars. Kilmer emphasizes the importance of checking this battery to avoid getting stranded, a point often glossed over in media narratives.
The Cost of Battery Replacement
Kilmer delves into the high cost of replacing the main battery in electric cars. Using a BMW i3 as an example, he reveals that a new battery can cost between $18,000 and $20,000, which is often more than the car’s value. Even opting for a remanufactured or used battery carries significant risks and costs. I believe this is a crucial aspect that potential EV buyers need to consider, as battery degradation over time is inevitable.
Challenges with Repairs and Maintenance
Repairing electric cars is not as straightforward as the media might suggest. Kilmer points out that diagnosing and fixing issues in EVs requires specialized equipment and expertise, which are not as widely available as for traditional cars. For instance, Teslas do not have a standard OBD port, making it difficult for independent mechanics to access diagnostic information. This limitation can lead to higher repair costs and dependency on dealership services.
Environmental and Efficiency Concerns
While electric cars are often touted as environmentally friendly, Kilmer raises concerns about the overall sustainability of EVs. He notes that the production and disposal of batteries involve significant environmental impact. Moreover, issues like tire wear and the need for air conditioning in EVs add to the overall energy consumption. These factors challenge the notion that electric cars are the ultimate solution to environmental problems.
Practicality of Charging Infrastructure
The practicality of charging an electric car is another area where the media narrative falls short, according to Kilmer. He explains that installing a Level 2 charger at home can cost thousands of dollars and may require significant modifications to the house’s electrical system. Furthermore, charging times can be lengthy, especially for larger batteries, making the convenience of EVs questionable for some users.
Economic Viability
Kilmer argues that, from an economic perspective, owning an electric car may not be as viable as it seems. The high initial costs, coupled with expensive maintenance and repair, can outweigh the savings on fuel. He suggests that leasing an electric car might be a better option for those interested in the technology, as it avoids the long-term financial risks associated with battery degradation and potential repairs.
Personal Experiences and Anecdotes
Kilmer shares personal anecdotes to illustrate his points, such as his struggles with a BMW’s proprietary lug nuts and a flat tire incident. These stories highlight the practical difficulties and unexpected challenges that can arise with electric vehicles. His experiences resonate with many drivers who have faced similar issues, reinforcing the idea that electric cars are not as hassle-free as often portrayed.
“Electrical Issues”
People in the comments shared their thoughts: “I work next to a place that repairs Teslas. The guys who work there all drive Honda and Toyota. Smart guys.”
Another commenter said: “Electrical cars with electrical issues?…the heck you say.”
Finally, one person concluded: “Electrification would have been a great opportunity to implement a battery standard for modules, but out of corporate greed every manufacturer has to sell you his own overpriced soup.”
Future of Electric Vehicles
Looking ahead, Kilmer expresses skepticism about the current state of electric vehicle technology. He believes that significant advancements, such as the development of solid-state batteries and improvements in the electrical grid, are necessary before EVs can become a truly practical and widespread solution. Until then, he advises caution and careful consideration for anyone thinking about making the switch to electric.
Overstated Environmental Benefits
What do you think? Are the environmental benefits of electric cars being overstated when considering the entire lifecycle of the vehicle? How can consumers make informed decisions about EVs when faced with potentially biased media coverage? What steps can be taken to improve the accessibility and affordability of electric car repairs?
Find out more by watching the full video on Scotty Kilmer’s YouTube channel here.
