In a recent episode of “The Megyn Kelly Show,” host Megyn Kelly sat down with Mike Rowe, the writer and star of “Something to Stand For,” to discuss the growing distrust Americans have in corporate media. Rowe shared his thoughts on the erosion of journalistic integrity, the loss of skepticism towards those in power, and the shift in the goals of today’s journalists. Let’s dive into their conversation and explore the issues they discussed.
The Decline of Trust in Media
Mike Rowe began by addressing the significant decline in trust that Americans have in corporate media. He pointed out that the media’s role has shifted from being a watchdog of power to an entity that often aligns itself with those in power. This erosion of skepticism has led to a massive trust gap between the public and the press. I think this observation is critical because a free press should ideally serve as a check on government and corporate power, ensuring transparency and accountability.
The Shift in Journalistic Goals
Rowe and Kelly discussed how the primary goal of journalists has shifted from seeking the truth to gaining power and popularity. Rowe emphasized that journalists should strive to be respected rather than liked, underscoring the importance of integrity over personal gain.
A Class of Elites
He lamented the loss of the “scrappy, working-class” journalists who once dominated the field, replaced by a class of elites who are often more interested in maintaining their status than challenging authority. This shift, he argued, has led to a less effective and more complacent media landscape.
The Influence of Preparation and Performance
Rowe highlighted how modern political debates have become more about performance and preparation than genuine discourse. He contrasted the meticulous coaching and rehearsals of today’s politicians with the eloquent, spontaneous rhetoric of historical figures. This focus on performance over substance, according to Rowe, diminishes the authenticity of political communication and contributes to public cynicism. I believe this insight sheds light on why many people feel disconnected from political processes and leaders today.
Walter Cronkite and the Loss of Credibility
Reflecting on the era of Walter Cronkite, Rowe noted that there was a time when news anchors could end their broadcasts with the phrase “And that’s the way it is,” and be believed. Today, however, such statements are met with skepticism and disbelief. Rowe argued that the media’s failure to maintain its role as an impartial observer has led to this credibility crisis. As someone who values reliable information, I find this decline in media trust particularly troubling, as it hampers our ability to make informed decisions.
The Importance of Skepticism
Rowe stressed the need for heightened skepticism in today’s media environment, noting that the press has become less critical of those in power. He called for journalists to reclaim their role as skeptics, holding the powerful accountable regardless of personal feelings. This call to action is crucial, as a vigilant and questioning press is essential for a healthy democracy. I agree with Rowe that without a skeptical media, the public is left to navigate a sea of misinformation and propaganda.
The Impact on Society
The conversation also touched on how this erosion of trust in media impacts society at large. Rowe pointed out that the lack of trustworthy journalism leaves the public without reliable sources of information, leading to increased cynicism and confusion. This, in turn, affects everything from political participation to social cohesion. I believe that rebuilding trust in media is a fundamental challenge that must be addressed to restore faith in our democratic institutions.
“Truth Doesn’t Matter”
People in the comments shared their thoughts on the topic: “I miss the country I grew up in! Everything stinks today, pro sports, corporations and the news media outlets! Truth doesn’t matter to this generation that can’t write or read a mechanical clock!”
One commenter added: “The slow rise of the public’s dependency on the government and the apathy of the average citizen has led us to this point.”
Another person said: “Bearing witness on the Commander in Chief was never so tough. I used to roll my eyes whenever I heard the President, but I never had to hold my nose before this one.”
A Critical Issue
The discussion between Megyn Kelly and Mike Rowe highlights a critical issue facing modern society: the erosion of trust in corporate media. Rowe’s insights into the loss of journalistic integrity, the shift in goals, and the importance of skepticism offer a sobering look at the state of today’s media landscape. As we navigate this complex environment, it’s essential to remain vigilant and critical, demanding higher standards from those who inform and influence public opinion.
Regaining Public Trust
What do you think? How can the media regain public trust in an era of widespread skepticism and misinformation? What steps can journalists take to ensure they remain impartial and critical of those in power? How does the shift from truth-seeking to popularity-seeking impact the quality of journalism?
To hear the full discussion, watch the video on Megyn Kelly’s YouTube channel here.
