Recessed Lights and Greenwash - Green Building Elements

Recessed Lights and Greenwash

Recessed Ceiling Lights and PendantsRecessed can lighting is a familiar method of lighting rooms.  Rather than having fixtures protruding into the space, the light source is hidden in a recess in the ceiling, reducing glare.  But, when the ceiling above is insulated, the can light fixture is a potential source of air leaks and thermal bridging.

I recently got a press release from a company advertising a product to quickly and easily “convert” recessed can lights to a pendant light look.  But, after a brief look, it turns out to be a particularly bad case of greenwash.

Like sticking a ‘Hybrid’ label on an SUV to make it more efficient

  The company advertises its product “reduces air leaks” around the recessed light, but there is no gasket or other means of sealing the cover plate, so it is unlikely to do much of anything in terms of reducing air leaks out of the box.  More to the point, there is nothing that this kit does that addresses the original problem of an inefficient light fixture creating an insulation gap in the ceiling.  In that way, this is like sticking a ‘Hybrid’ label on an SUV, or like putting a hybrid shell on top of a non-hybrid chassis and thinking that would make it a more efficient vehicle.  It makes it look like the other, but underneath, none of the key issues have been addressed.

Their greenwash also notes “energy efficient lighting,” though there is no mention of how this increases efficiency.  In fact, a recessed can fixture can be more efficient than a standard incandescent.  Halogen lights are commonly available for recessed can lights, and are more efficient than standard incandescent bulbs.  Rather than using the recommended 100 watt incandescent bulb the manufacturer suggests with the conversion kit pendant, a 60 watt halogen bulb would produce nearly the same light level and would last slightly longer than the conventional bulb.  But halogen lights are generaly less attractive for direct view.  The one pendant light fixture in my own house is one of the few places where I have not replaced an incandescent bulb with a compact fluorescent, and that is because it is directly visible.

Proper selection of recessed can lights

Greenwash aside, there are two kinds of recessed can lights: IC fixtures and Non-IC fixtures.  Non-IC fixtures must have insulation kept from directly coming in contact to prevent overheating and the risk of fire.  The IC fixture (the IC stands for “insulation contact”) is completely sealed and can have insulation placed right against it and on top of it.  IC fixtures are also generally built tighter, with seals to reduce or prevent air leaks.  In an insulated ceiling, an IC fixture should always be used, to allow the insulation against the fixture without any gaps that will contribute to heat loss.  Non-IC recessed light fixtures are cheaper to produce, so naturally they are often found in homes where builders have cut corners to save money.

If you are building new, or are renovating, be sure to use IC fixtures where appropriate. But if the ceiling above a recessed fixture is another floor, the non-IC fixtures are adequate, and IC fixtures are not necessary. Removing and replacing a non-IC fixture in a ceiling is a good step to take as part of an overall home improvement to tighten the house against air and energy leaks.

If you like the look of pendants, this does offer an inexpensive (and reversible) method for getting the look without getting involved in a more extensive renovation. But don’t fool yourself into thinking that this is going to be a big energy savings step for you.

Related articles on Green Building Elements:
How Not to Greenwash Your Building Product
When to Turn Off Fluorescent Lights
Old School Green Meets Greenwashing at PCBC

image source: LA Times ‘Pardon Our Dust’


About the Author

  • What is your problem with hybrid SUV’s?

  • What is your problem with hybrid SUV’s?

  • It’s not the little sticker that says “Hybrid” that makes it a better vehicle, it’s what’s inside the vehicle that matters. Likewise with recessed lights.

    Making a recessed can light look like a pendant light doesn’t do anything to improve its energy efficiency or its performance. If you have a carpet-bombing house with non-IC fixtures in an insulated ceiling, making them look like pendants will do nothing to improve the insulation or the energy performance of the house. The company that was promoting them to me as a green improvement doing a disservice to anyone who buys their junk thinking it will somehow help save energy.

    I’m okay with hybrid SUVs (though I think there are too many SUVs used by people who don’t really need them, but that’s a whole separate discussion for some other time).

  • It’s not the little sticker that says “Hybrid” that makes it a better vehicle, it’s what’s inside the vehicle that matters. Likewise with recessed lights.

    Making a recessed can light look like a pendant light doesn’t do anything to improve its energy efficiency or its performance. If you have a carpet-bombing house with non-IC fixtures in an insulated ceiling, making them look like pendants will do nothing to improve the insulation or the energy performance of the house. The company that was promoting them to me as a green improvement doing a disservice to anyone who buys their junk thinking it will somehow help save energy.

    I’m okay with hybrid SUVs (though I think there are too many SUVs used by people who don’t really need them, but that’s a whole separate discussion for some other time).

  • Tim

    If someone is truly interested in a recessed light, and can spend a little more, there may be another option. I’ve seen it on a few shows on the Planet Green. It’s the Solatube light that provides sunlight in the day and allows a recessed light to be inserted into the same area for lighting at night. It’s two great items rolled into one.

    And, yes, I always laugh at the hybrid SUV commercials. “Go from 16 miles per gallon to… 17!”

  • Tim

    If someone is truly interested in a recessed light, and can spend a little more, there may be another option. I’ve seen it on a few shows on the Planet Green. It’s the Solatube light that provides sunlight in the day and allows a recessed light to be inserted into the same area for lighting at night. It’s two great items rolled into one.

    And, yes, I always laugh at the hybrid SUV commercials. “Go from 16 miles per gallon to… 17!”